Teen Girl Gaming: The New Paradigm
Girl Games Research and Development Lab
Laura Groppe, President
All rights reserved.
Do not quote without author's permission.
First and Foremost
We want you to know what girls really want out of gaming, because it is Girl Games' mission to provide a voice for teen girls and empower them as consumers. We talk to real girls who tell us what they want from the Gaming Industry. Now we're telling you.
The New Paradigm in Girl Gaming
The purpose of this study was to give you a clearer understanding of how teen girls feel about gaming in general, as well as to delve deeper into their specific attitudes and preferences regarding actual and ideal gaming experiences for girls. Nearly all of the girls communicated feelings of frustration with the current level of interest by the gaming industry in girls, as evidenced by both the dearth of well-designed games for girls, as well as nearly non-existent girl-related game marketing. When we asked girls what kinds of games they really wanted, the popularity of racing games was surprising. If the gaming industry continues to erroneously assume that girls' interests are as limited as current game marketing to girls seems to indicate, it risks further alienating the growing, lucrative and interested teen girl market.
Data
This report combines data from extensive open-ended e-mail surveys and numerous focus groups.
Overview of Findings
General Gaming Attitudes and Preferences
Platforms
Based on their response patterns to gaming platform surveys, most of the girls we talked to play online games most, followed by CD-ROM and Console games. (See Figure 1). Several factors are universally important to the girl gamer:

Online
Recent surveys and focus groups have revealed several characteristics of online gaming that girls value highly:
"AOL game shows are pretty neat, cause you play against other people" Anonymous, 16
"When you have to pay for a game that sux, and pay a lot for one that you can only play for less than a half an hour." Kris, 15
"You can quit in the middle and no one gets mad at you, and there aren't a million pieces to set up" Melanie, 16
Notes on Downloading: Girls' feelings on the process of downloading software or games before they can play tend toward:
"I don't mind as long as it doesn't take forever" Elaynah, 15
"It sucks major ass," Thuy, 16
"I'm afraid it'll have bugs and destroy my hard drive."
Rachel, 17
It is therefore advisable to offer online games that are compatible with lower common denominator pre-loaded software. If a site is confident that its offerings are virus-free, it would be a good idea to post a confidence statement of some kind.
Breken, age 14 is an avid online gamer:

CD-ROM Gaming
In a recent platform preferences survey, several factors emerged as important to girls in the CD-ROM gaming experience:
"CD-ROM games are really great because you can play and the levels keep loading really fast. There usually aren't lines at the top like in some console games like NFL2K and stuff like that. Online games are kinda slow sometimes." Joleen, 15
"Blood and gore isn't necessarily offensive, it's just not interesting." Holli, 18
Console Gaming
Girl Console gamers are a breed apart. That's not to say that they don't enjoy other platforms, but as primarily console gamers, they have some unique characteristics:
"I like console games cause you can just pop them in and play. You don't have to worry about if you need to download something or not." Kristen, 17
"It's fun when you're competing in the game." Jen, 13

Girl Cannot Live On Fluff Alone: Game Styles Girls Really Want
Games for girls shouldn't necessarily aspire to be the answer to gender inequities in Western society. They should first and foremost be fun. Armed with knowledge of what girls repeatedly say they want out of gaming, developers have the chance to do it right from the beginning and avoid many of the mistakes made (and being made) in "boys" games.
Racing Games: Girls Are Not Trophies!
In both focus groups and e-mail panel discussions, girls say frequently that they love auto racing games. Mario Kart and Crazy Taxi were mentioned frequently, though Crazy Taxi's TV Ads were criticized for depicting the only female character as a large-breasted "psycho". Unfortunately for game publishers, girls are often turned off from current racing titles due to "trophy syndrome", or the pervasiveness racing games that portray female characters as bikini-clad bimbos who hand out trophies and pose with the winner who is almost certainly male.
Factors girls said would make a cool racing game:
"Well a girl car is like navy blue, maybe slick. All the cars on a game are boy cars because they are like huge trucks or red with yellow racing strips with a huge muffler and all that stuff...girls wouldn't have that on their cars!" Brielle, 16
Sports Games: Bouncing Balls and Snowfall Rule
In a recent survey, we asked 120 girls what kind of sports game they'd create if they could. The pie chart below summarizes the sports they mentioned.

|
Ball Sports |
Winter Sports |
Water Sports |
Adventure |
|
Basketball |
Ice Skating |
Surfing |
Mazes |
|
Soccer |
Snowboarding |
Swimming |
Gladiators |
|
Basketball, Girl's |
Ice Hockey |
Water Skiing |
|
|
Volleyball |
|||
|
Tennis |
Indoor Sports |
"Social" Sports |
|
|
Baseball |
Cheerleading |
Dating |
|
|
Volleyball, Girl's |
Gymnastics |
Flirting |
|
|
Football |
Boxing |
Fashion |
|
|
Softball |
Shopping |
||
|
Kickball |
Turf Sports |
||
|
Tennis, Girl's |
Track and Field |
Street Sports |
|
|
T-Ball |
Horseback Riding |
Skateboarding |
|
|
Soccer, Girl's |
Field Hockey |
Rollerblading |
|
|
Football, Girl's |
Golf |
||
Fighting Games: Yep, You Heard Me
Fighting games for girls can sometimes seem like an oxymoron, and while developing them can be a slippery slope, there is demand for them, and a game can be successful if it follows some basic girl guidelines.
"Cartoons are just less serious." Allison, 13
"In my opinion, shooting games are SOOO boring!" Becca, 16
"In Final Fantasy 7 and 8, there are strong female lead characters, not just skimpily-dressed eye-candy!" Anonymous, 17
Features of a Good Game: Variety is the Sugar and Spice of Life
"I think the most important thing in dealing with the addition of more girl gamers is simply adding more options. A racing game with only 4 cars is no fun. Neither is a fighting game with only 6 characters," Violet, 17
Emotional Payoffs of the Gaming Experience
For boys, extreme fantasies and over-the-top action combined with high-intensity violence and gore make for a great gaming "buzz." Designing a stimulating game for girls is not so simple.
"If you can compete against other people or compare your score it's fun." Nithya, 18
"A game is fun when you play other people online and you get to meet new people and talk while playing." Caitlyn, 16
"It's fun if it's a bit challenging, but not a lot cuz then your brain will go crazy tryin' to think it out and you'll get a big huge headache and that's a drag." Mayumi, 16
"A game is fun when you get to make things or be in charge and have to find things." Melanie, 17
Visual Payoffs of the Gaming Experience
Girls have a keen eye for details. In gaming discussions, many girls mentioned "good" graphics as an important factor in the games they like. "Bad" graphics were mentioned frequently as a major deal-breaker. More focused research is needed to clearly define "good" and "bad" graphics from the girl's point of view, but there are some general guidelines based on what girls told us about how games should look:
"Creating games for girls, you usually want to stick to cool stuff like colorful graphics of flowers, rainbows, stars and funky fonts with color and a lot of cool music" Brielle, 16
Developing & Marketing Games for Teen Girls: Not As Pink As You Think
Tip #1 for marketing video games for girls: start DOING it! Before game publishers complain any further that girls aren't buying games, they should take a good hard look at the marketing efforts (if any) that have been deployed.