Playing by the Rules:
Video Games and Cultural Policy
A University of Chicago Cultural Policy Program Conference
October 26-27, 2001
Current Conference Agenda
Friday October 26
Museum of Contemporary Art, 220 E. Chicago Ave
Public Roundtable Discussions
1. Video Games and Civil Society
9:00 - 11:00 a.m.
Moderator: Robert Pippin, Raymond W. and Martha Hilpert Gruner Distinguished Service Professor, Committee on Social Thought and Department of Philosophy, University of Chicago
What is the impact of video games on the various aspects of civil society? What kinds of social relations do various game genres and game-playing formats promote? Some say that video games foster a healthy competitiveness, and, in their multi-player internet manifestations, contain vast new possibilities for community-building. Others see video games as isolating and damaging to both individuals and communities. What does the research show?
Confirmed Panelists
Sara Diamond, The Banff Centre for the Arts
Marjorie Heins, Free Expression Policy Project, National Coalition Against Censorship
J.C. Herz, Joystick Nation, Inc.
Seth Killian, Shoryuken.com
W.J.T. Mitchell, Art History and Editor of Critical Inquiry, University of Chicago
Celia Pearce, Claire Trevor School of the Arts, UC-Irvine
Eugene Provenzo, Jr., Education, University of Miami
Cass Sunstein, University of Chicago Law School
Eric Zimmerman, gameLab, Inc.
11:30 a.m. - 1:00 p.m.
Moderator: Colm O'Muircheartaigh, Public Policy and NORC, University of Chicago
What ways of thinking and learning, intellectual skills and habits, does game playing encourage or discourage? How much influence do interactive games have on the cognitive development of players of different ages? Are the skills of game playing transferable to other educational endeavors, and if so, how? Answers to these questions should help policymakers identify and support best practices in the fusion of video game technology and education.
Confirmed Panelists
Hubert Dreyfus, Philosophy, University of California, Berkeley
Noah Falstein, The Inspiracy
Laura Groppe, girlGames Research Lab
Terry Hackett, eLearning Division, Deloitte Consulting
Yasmin Kafai, Kids Interactive Design Studios, UCLA
Alan Pope, Langley Research Center, NASA
Marc Prensky, games2train.com
Andrew Rosenfield, UNext
2:00 - 4:00 p.m.
Moderator: Jack Doppelt, Northwestern University Medill School of Journalism
Expert witnesses debate what the research tells us about the psychological effects, if any, of playing violent video games; policy analysts and policymakers discuss if and how they would formulate regulations or create incentives; industry representatives and anti-violence activists clarify the stakes involved; and legal experts assess the constitutionality of these proposals.
Confirmed Panelists
Craig Anderson, Psychology, Iowa State University
Mary Engle, Federal Trade Commission
Jonathan Freedman, University of Toronto
Henry Jenkins, Comparative Media Studies, MIT
Gerard Jones, author of Killing Monsters: Why Children Need Fantasy Games, Superheroes and Make-Believe Violence
Marsha Kinder, Cinema-Television, USC
Doug Lowenstein, Interactive Digital Software Association
Geoffrey Stone, Provost and Law School, University of Chicago
David Walsh, Media and the Family
Saturday October 27
On the University of Chicago Campus
Donnelley Biological Sciences Learning Center (BSLC)
924 East 57th Street, Rooms 205, 218
Paper Panel Sessions for Academic and Policy Stakeholders
Session 1
9:00 - 10:30 a.m.
Panel 1A: Convergences of creativity and commerce: what is the future of interactive game arts?
Chair: Tom Gunning, Cinema and Media Studies, University of Chicago
As computers and digital communications pervade all areas of life, games spread with them. What role does the game play in the new digital economy? Are we entering an age of ubiquitous entertainment, or entertainment monopolies, and if so, what are the effects on culture? Does convergence help or hinder independent production and variety of games? What kinds of interactivity do games bring to other electronic media applications? And is there a public interest in shaping relations among these cultural industries?
Confirmed Panelists
Richard Epstein, Law School, University of Chicago
Noah Falstein, The Inspiracy
Seth Killian, Shoryuken.com
Stephan Meyers, consultant, wireless entertainment
Celia Pearce, Claire Trevor School of the Arts, UC-Irvine
Panel 1B: The Violence Debate I: What does the evidence show?
Chair: John Cacioppo, Psychology, University of Chicago
What does the best research on video games and violence really tell us (or fail to tell us) about the relation between violent video game play and violent behavior?
Confirmed Panelists
Craig Anderson, Psychology, Iowa State University
Jonathan Freedman, Psychology, University of Toronto
Jeanne Funk, Psychology, University of Toledo
Jeffrey Goldstein, Social and Organizational Psychology, Utrecht University
Session 2
11:00 a.m. – 12:30 p.m.
Panel 2A: The Violence Debate II: The First Amendment, the FTC Report, and Legal Strategies
Chair: J. Mark Schuster, Urban Studies and Planning, MIT and Visiting Professor of Cultural Policy, Harris Graduate School of Public Policy Studies, University of Chicago
What regulatory tools and legal weapons are available to those interested in monitoring, controlling or sanctioning those who violate agreed-upon self-imposed standards? What protections from such censorship efforts do video games enjoy under the First Amendment? What does history tell us about efforts to regulate – and efforts to self-regulate – popular culture?
Confirmed Panelists
Mary Engle, Federal Trade Commission
Jeffrey Goldstein, Social & Organizational Psychology, University of Utrecht
Marjorie Heins, Free Expression Policy Project, National Coalition Against Censorship
Marsha Kinder, Cinema-Television, USC
Gail Markels, Interactive Digital Software Association (IDSA)
David Walsh, Media and the Family
Panel 2B: Gamers and Gender
Chair: Lawrence Rothfield, associate professor, English & Comparative Literature and faculty director, Cultural Policy Center
How can we best understand how computer games affect the gender attitudes and identities of those who play them? And what steps could be taken to make video games more open to a variety of subjective experiences?
Confirmed Panelists
Jeanne Funk, Psychology, University of Toledo
Laura Groppe, Girl Games Inc.
J.C. Herz, Joystick Nation, Inc.
Henry Jenkins, Comparative Media Studies, MIT
Gerard Jones, author of Killing Monsters: Why Children Need Fantasy Games, Superheroes and Make-Believe Violence
Session 3
2:00 - 3:30 p.m.
Panel 3A: Playing With Your Brain
Chair: Howard Margolis, Public Policy, University of Chicago
What does recent research about childhood development, models of intelligence, and different learning styles tell us about the impact of video-game play on the minds of young people?
Confirmed Panelists
Terry Hackett, e-learning Division, Deloitte Consulting
Yasmin Kafai, Kids Interactive Design Studios, UCLA
Alan Pope, Langley Research Center, NASA
Marc Prensky, games2train.com
Eugene Provenzo, Jr., Education, University of Miami
Panel 3B: The Future of Video Games as an Art
Chair: Kim Rorschach, The David and Alfred Smart Museum of Art at the University of Chicago
The video game industry today is a magnet for creative talent, talent reflected in the increasing complexity, sophistication, beauty, and variety of game design. How is the art form itself likely to evolve over the next decade? Should we be concerned about the fact that this creative surge is taking place for the most in the commercial sector? Should policies be devised to encourage the development of independent and/or non-profit video-game design (comparable to independent film)?
Confirmed Panelists
Sara Diamond, The Banff Centre for the Arts
Joe McKay, computer-based artist
Feng Mengbo, video game artist, Beijing
Ellen Sandor, (art)n
Yuri Tsivian, Cinema and Media Studies, University of Chicago
Hamza Walker, The Renaissance Society
Eric Zimmerman, gameLab, Inc.
Final session: 7:00 - 9:00 p.m.
Video on Video: Documentaries of Video Game Culture
Moderator: TBA
Two University of Chicago cinema and media studies graduate students, Kaveh Askari and Michelle Puetz, have produced a documentary of video game subcultures in the Chicago area. This evening we will screen their work, followed by Q&A with the filmmakers and some video game enthusiasts who appear in the documentary. All are welcome to attend.